Wednesday, February 11, 2015

A Fable Agreed Upon

We noted the other day that two balloonists who crossed the Pacific were touted as having "made history" by the media. The feat was certainly unique, but at True Archives we have to question the claim of "history" being made by the two daring aeronauts.

History has become one of the more abused words in this nightmare we call the digital age. Those who have never picked up a book (yet who have logged untold hours watching Ken Burns films) consider themselves well versed in "history." People who go into hock to purchase the latest mind-numbing electronic toys have their credit "history" checked. A television network that wallows in such visual tripe as "Swamp People" and "Pawnography" has the nerve to call itself the "History Channel." In recognition of this fetid semantic stew we decided to check on the meaning of the word "history" in the Oxford English Dictionary (yes we used the online version; who ever said we are consistent?) and here is the first definition listed:

A written narrative constituting a continuous chronological record of important or public events (esp. in a particular place) or of a particular trend, institution, or person's life. Common in the titles of books.


Now did the intrepid balloonists mentioned above actually compose a written narrative whilst sailing through the air over Hawaii, or were they simply jotting down notes into an iPad or something? If the latter, which is highly likely, they no more “made history” than you did when you typed your last 140 characters into Twitter to describe your lunch. Real history is a NARRATIVE, and it is published in BOOKS, which used to be kept in LIBRARIES.

Of course, libraries like that are...wait for it..."history."

Wednesday, January 14, 2015

The Bell Tolls For Thee

One of our founders at True Archives has had occasion to travel to three international conferences on archives in recent years, and the hardest thing to find at each one was a session dealing with actual three-dimensional, information-bearing objects. Most presenters spent their time talking about “metadata” and insuring the “authenticity” of electronic records, but actual presentations on how one arranges and describes hundreds of cubic feet of file boxes (a task which is still very much a part of the profession) were almost completely absent. It's as if our colleagues are uninterested in anything they cannot see on a TV screen.

The reason for this is simple. Information Scientists have infiltrated the archival profession and are slowly poisoning the minds of impressionable young graduates just entering the occupation. Just look at the so-called “education calendar” of courses offered by the Society of American Archivists and you will see the unmistakable fingerprints of Information Science. Course after course dealing with zeros and ones, and nought dealing with actual objects. The result will be a cadre of young archivists who will have never suffered a paper cut, or who have even read a document handwritten in cursive. They won’t know a real record even if it “bytes” them.

It is a shame how these fiendish Biblioposers have obliterated the once proud profession of librarians, but now they come for our own colleagues. To paraphrase Thoreau, “wherever an archivist goes, Information Scientists will pursue him and paw him with their dirty institutions, and, if they can, constrain him to belong to their desperate odd-fellow society.”

Monday, December 29, 2014

Are You Experienced?

It turns out that Jimi Hendrix's inquiry was quite appropriate. Here at True Archives we have noted the rise of a new pair of buzzwords from the minions of Information Science. “User Experience” (or UX for the English-reading impaired) is a term bandied about that describes the effort to measure the efficiency of online tools for the attention-challenged masses. It seems that the process of dumbing down a web page so that your average browsing buffoon will linger before clicking away to YouTube is becoming a genuine subfield of study, and perhaps that is a good thing. In a world where fifteen seconds of fame is becoming about ten seconds too long for most people’s intellect, getting your message across quickly is essential. However, we at True Archives see a problem with this latest hula-hoop of the Biblioposers.

One definition of the word experience is “the knowledge or mastery of an event or subject gained through involvement in or exposure to it.” If that is the case, then User Experience must be regulated to the rubbish bin of failed efforts. No one gains mastery of historical investigation when Information Scientists continually make it easier for troglodytes to have the illusion they are doing actual research. Besides, no one can have the virtual “experience” of discovery once that discovery has already been made for them. These helpful online tools are the digital equivalent of a canned "hunt" at some safari club where rich guys pay to shoot a lion that has just been released from a cage.

Instead of making a digital surrogate of document, we would like to see the enhancement of “user experience” for researchers who actually get off the couch and come to our repositories. Stickers like the ones seen on election day proudly proclaiming “I researched!” might be in order. Perhaps free cocktails and snacks in the lobby to welcome historians before they enter the sanctum sactorium of the reading room would be a nice experience. Comfortable leather covered chairs, with real incandescent bulb lighting makes a great ambiance for the researcher. We might even try to improve our services, like a real effort to accelerate the retrieval of requested items. Who knows, those who experience amenities like that may learn to prefer it to a screen, and rediscover the delight in actually holding and reading a book. (We would elaborate on this last point if we were not so busy building a really cool historical photographs database for our library that allows keyword searching for images of our school...)

Friday, December 12, 2014

Libraries on the "Make"

Reacting to the “crisis of relevancy,” Biblioposers have gone to extreme lengths to maintain their continued employment. Libraries, once revered as the repository of printed human knowledge, have abandoned this duty as they grasp at any passing fad to attract supporters. An excellent example is the rise of the “makerspace” movement among libraries. Stocked with transistors and motherboards, these little electronic co-ops are just the sort of thing you would expect to see at a YMCA, cub scout headquarters or a senior center, but it stretches the limits of credulity to see them as an appropriate function of a library. What does hot-wiring a television remote control have to do with books, anyway?

Perhaps a better question to ask our angst-ridden cousins of the library world is, “Why stop there?” If stocking 3D printers with plastic goo for patrons to make Disney action figures is a proper role for libraries, how about a cupcake bakery, complete with flower, sugar, and colorful sprinkles? Then your growing cadre of illiterate users can work on upping the diabetes statistics for the nation. Perhaps an auto repair bay might be in order. I know its getting as hard to find an American who can work on his own car as it is to find one who reads, but such a service might help taxpayers look more kindly on the library. Hand loom weaving studios might be a great addition too, although the visual reminder of the first trade made obsolete in the Industrial Revolution might make Biblioposers uncomfortable as they face extinction in the "Information Age."

But really, libraries, as long as you are not using those books, why not send them over to the archives where they can be taken care of? After all, archivists have not added a Ronald McDonald playhouse to their operations and therefore may be able to find the room to store the printed legacy of the human race. Somebody’s got to do it, and you Information Scientists apparently don’t want to.

Wednesday, November 26, 2014

Bibliocide

Imagine a future where reading is unknown, where sentence structure is continually punctuated with the words "like" and "you know," where memorization skills are reduced to knowing which button to push. Difficult to picture? Just look around; it's happening right now.

There can be little argument that the widespread availability of cheap, mass produced books and periodicals in the late nineteenth century led to the formation of the most literate populace the world has ever seen. In a culture without distractions, reading became a popular, cheap form of amusement which was fostered by the rise of the lending library. Free circulation of literature and texts truly made the public library the "people's university." Sure, plenty of people were reading crap like "Deadwood Dick," but at least they were reading.

Fast forward to the twenty-first century, where distractions in hand-held toys sap young minds of memorization powers, and libraries jettison books like a sinking ship throwing cargo overboard. Slowly young people are losing the ability to spend extended time periods perusing text, and the library has forsaken its primary purpose as a repository of those texts. So eager to appear "relevant," Biblioposers are touting eBooks as some sort of panacea that will reawaken the reading ethic among knuckle-dragging internet junkies. "Makerspaces" are taking the place of book shelving to allow library patrons the opportunity to hotwire garage door openers and produce effigies of Jennifer Lawrence on 3D printers. More and more floor space is devoted to screens and keyboards. As more Biblioposers pursue this tack, books become the victims, and have become the only thing with a spine in the whole library.

Archives must step forward to rescue the codex before it becomes extinct. Perhaps the future does not hold a populace that will resemble H. G. Wells' Eloi, or the drones who feature in the recent (and widely ignored) film Idiocracy. If so, they will be happy we rescued these under-appreciated artifacts; if not, at least they will be on hand to demonstrate to whatever alien race visits our planet a thousand years from now that a few brave souls tried to stem the tide of mass book murder. As it looks now, those brave souls will be archivists, and not librarians.




Monday, November 3, 2014

Buyer Be Aware!

In the quest to procure new and exciting research collections for their patrons, archivists often go to great lengths. Having an excruciatingly boring tea with the Daughters of the American Revolution, singing loudly off key at a Rotary luncheon, or even attending a politically charged local meeting of “Fanatics in Search of a Cause,” are all ways archivists have sacrificed their comfort zone and even their sanity to butter up potential donors. Another source for good archival stuff can be found in online auctions, either the highbrow ones where astronaut patches get hawked next to Lincoln signatures, or the more commonplace eBay, a giant, never-ending garage sale of items classified ridiculous to sublime.

The problem with eBay is the use by some savvy buyers of “sniping” software that allows them to come in literally at the last second to dash your acquisition dreams to smithereens. But perhaps there are more sinister dangers from this online auction powerhouse. Suppose the Information Scientists, in their desire to stamp out all resistance from analog information lovers, decide to entrap our archival brethren with offerings that are not quite the same thing as advertised? Even Biblioposers could get into the act, exacting revenge from archives as they come to realize that we will, indeed, inherit the earth (as far as books go.) Bottom line: double check that auction listing description! There could be danger in the mailbox!


Monday, October 27, 2014

The Age of Unenlightenment

They work tirelessly to digitize the heritage of mankind, tag it with “metadata,” and make it available to the entire globe without charge through open access. It sounds like a boon to the human race, a team of superheroes who selflessly work to elevate our collective consciousness and bring an enlightenment to society unmatched since the seventeenth century awakening of our forefathers (and mothers). Yes, the Information Scientist is truly the savior of our species, and their work will not stop until all have reached an understanding of the universe akin to the gods.

Age of Enlightenment? No, we here at True Archives know that this is the dawn of the Dark Ages; a strange world without print, and without memory. The Information Scientists have been busy stirring up their witches brew since the dawn of the internet in the 1980s, but where, pray tell, are the masses of smarter people for all their efforts? Instead of using this electronic tool ostensibly built for edification, we have millions who use it for nothing more than idle browsing for merchandise or inane chatter. Most of the slack-jawed electronic addicts who no longer have to use any brain power to memorize phone numbers, or even directions to the nearest liquor store, are hardly using that spare cranial space to improve our collective lot. Worst of all, with the ongoing effort to digitize everything and destroy its analog counterpart, the Information Scientist is simultaneously promoting a google-brained generation that will no longer know how to read extended blocks of text, nor have the resources to even regain that skill in the future. Unless, of course, archivists step in to save those books.

Behold the Information Scientist and his minions! See them for what they are! Rage against the gathering gloom! Do not go softly into that dark night! See them for what they are! (Wait a minute. Didn't I just say that? I can't remember...)

Monday, September 29, 2014

This Mission Does Not Exist

Perhaps this is you. Your boss (or other important resource allocator) demands that you go out and collect an important batch of papers that you KNOW have been promised to another institution. Sure, you could say "no" and hope your professional ethics can protect you, but then again, who wants to really test THAT safety net? You have no choice but to appear in the enemy's territory and stealthily contact the donor, hoping that your Ryder truck won't attract any more attention on campus than a batch of freshmen playing "humans and zombies." You load up the boxes, get a signature on the deed of gift, and hie yourself off to your own repository and unload the loot.

Archives are not supposed to be a competitive business. Like Rodney King, we should all plaintively shout "Can't we all just get along?" when it is time to shake the bushes for new material. But sometimes bagging a trophy collection that your boss may want requires tossing the collection development policy to the wind, and a willingness to engage in covert donor contact. Be very careful, and burn this entry after reading.


Thursday, September 18, 2014

The Doomsday eBook

In their never ending attempt to straddle the divide between electronic information access and books, Biblioposers know no shame. We have previously exposed their annual advocacy of the phony "Banned Books Week," but now we find an entirely new ritual they intend to promote. Read an eBook Day is a "celebration of modern storytelling" that encourages people to eschew print for a virtual reading experience on a computing device. The official website for this snake oil sale features a parade of glowing personal testimonials (although few contributors seem able to actually name a title they have read on their Kindles). Instead we find arguments that tout the convenience of the devices for readers whose hand arthritis prevents them from comfortably holding a real book. (Break from sarcasm: if these things help the disabled, they can indeed be considered a boon to mankind.)

Aside from physically challenged reader use (and the use by physically fit people who use them on their treadmill machines) we wonder if the widespread acceptance of eBooks is a good thing. There are a number of studies that question the true comprehension and retention of information gathered from a glowing screen. There may also be another, more evil, agenda at work here. Besides the built-in distraction features that allow shortened attention spans to skip from title to title (or even to break off to check email or cat videos) eBooks seem almost made to order for the excuses the Information Scientists need to justify their continuing disposal of print. Australian journalists have caught on to this doomsday scenario, and here at True Archives, we applaud their insightful warnings!


Monday, September 8, 2014

Bit by Bitmap They Are Building A Madhouse

The Information Scientists want us to make our material "accessible" by emulating their obsessive love affair with the internet. Claiming our carefully crafted finding aids do not go far enough in revealing the existence of documents, they demand we describe individual documents with all the care and exacting attention to detail as librarians of yore put into the cataloging of books. Unfortunately, the analogy is faulty, because the demands of the Information Scientist are more akin to the effort it would have taken Charles A. Cutter to catalog the individual pages of a given volume rather than a summation of its contents. And for what purpose, we may ask? To give the illusion of discovery to an end user? This Sisyphean task is more than just futile, it is maddening, and here at True Archives we sympathize with our brethren pushed to the brink of insanity because they are charged with dumbing down the process of historical investigation.